Untitled design 3 1
Back to all articles
Social Media

Why the most valuable sports influencers aren’t always athletes

By Kimmi Scadgell, Social & Media Account Manager.

Influencer marketing in sport has moved on from the days when a VIP pass and a decent camera angle were enough to pass for strategy. Today, the creators shaping the conversation are often the ones with the sharpest point of view, the strongest cultural instincts and the confidence to say something worth sharing. And that matters more than ever, especially when 74% of marketers are increasing their influencer budgets in 2026.

In many cases, the most valuable voices are not the athletes themselves, but the creators, commentators and community-led accounts who understand how sport lives online. They know what fans want to see, what they will share, and what turns a single moment into a wider cultural conversation.

For brands, that shift means the strongest sports partnerships are often built around relevance, not reach.


From access to perspective

For years, sports marketing focused heavily on access. If a creator could get close to the action, behind the scenes or into the VIP space, that was often enough to make the content feel valuable. But today’s audiences want more than proximity. They want personality, opinion, humour and interpretation.

That is why fan creators, niche commentators and meme pages are increasingly influential. They do not just show sport; they translate it. They turn live moments into relatable, highly shareable content that feels closer to how audiences actually experience an event online. In many ways, they are acting as cultural translators between sport and internet culture.

The result is a very different kind of influence. It is less polished, more participatory and often far more effective at driving engagement than official brand or rights-holder content. In fact, 69% of marketers say influencer-generated content performs better than brand-directed content, which says a lot about what audiences actually respond to.


Why relevance beats reach.

One of the biggest misconceptions in influencer marketing is that bigger always means better. In reality, a large following does not automatically equal a strong outcome. A creator with a smaller but highly engaged audience can often outperform a much larger name if their community is more relevant and more trusting.

That is especially true in sport, where audiences are often deeply invested and quick to spot content that feels forced. If a creator does not genuinely understand the culture around the event, the content can feel like decoration rather than contribution. The best partnerships feel natural because the creator already speaks the language of the audience.

Joshua Paul is a strong example of this in motorsport. Focused on F1 race weekends and Grand Prix events, he uses analogue photography shot on a 1913 Graflex to capture the sport from a perspective no one else in the space really offers. That distinct editorial angle has helped his work travel beyond social, with features in The New York Times, Esquire, The Guardian and Hypebeast, showing the value of having a voice that is both niche and culturally resonant.

This is where the most effective sports influencer strategies start to differ from traditional media plans. They are not built around simply broadcasting a message. They are built around identifying the voices that already shape how fans talk, react and participate.


The value of the full event cycle

Sport is no longer just a live moment. It is a content cycle that begins before the event and continues long after the final whistle. Anticipation, prediction posts, outfit reveals, travel content and pre-event chatter all help build momentum. Then, once the action starts, reactions, clips and commentary keep the conversation moving.

Some of the most shareable content happens after the event itself. Fans want reactions, analysis, memes and cultural takeaways. That means brands that only show up during the live moment risk missing the fuller story around the event. Creators help extend that story, turning one match or tournament into a multi-day social conversation. When creators keep the conversation alive across more moments, platforms and story beats, they multiply the touchpoints that ultimately drive more revenue for sports leagues, teams and the brands that fuel them.

Lifestyle crossover content is also a major part of this. Fashion, music, food and travel all help sporting events reach beyond their core fan base. That does not weaken the sport; done well, it widens the audience and deepens the sense that the event is part of a bigger cultural moment.


Beyond centre court: How creators extend Wimbledon’s cultural reach

Wimbledon is a strong example of how influence now works in sport. It is a global tennis tournament, but also a cultural moment where sport, style and social content all collide.

Influencer Morgan Riddle shows this well. Through GRWM videos and event-led content across TikTok, Instagram and YouTube, she has helped make tennis feel more fashionable, sociable and culturally relevant. Her coverage of the ATP Tour, including Wimbledon, the US Open and the Australian Open, has earned attention from Vogue, Harper’s Bazaar, and The New York Times Style, proving that creators can reshape how a sport is perceived.

And in 2025, Wimbledon especially leaned into fast, culturally aware content, with the tournament’s content manager sharing on LinkedIn that there were 5,844 posts (+9% YoY) on Wimbledon channels throughout the grass court season. That volume came from a mix of in-house real-time coverage, creator-led moments and UGC, rather than just planned posts or passive reposting.

The point is not to post more for the sake of it. It is to work with creators who understand the event, respect the audience and add something meaningful to the conversation.


Steps brands can take now

For brands looking to activate around sport, the first step is to define the objective clearly. Is the goal awareness, engagement, audience growth or conversion? Once that is clear, the creator strategy can follow.

From there, it is about choosing the right mix of voices. Smaller creators with highly aligned communities can be incredibly effective, particularly when paired with broader amplification across the right channels. The key is to brief for authenticity rather than control, and to give creators enough space to use their own voice.

Long-term partnerships also matter. When a creator works with a brand or event over time, the relationship feels more believable, and the content becomes part of an ongoing story rather than a one-off post. In sport, that consistency can be especially powerful because audiences are used to following narratives over time.


Building smarter sports influence

The future of sports influencer marketing is not about replacing athletes. It is about recognising that athletes, creators and fans all play different roles in shaping attention. Athletes may drive the moment, but creators often drive the conversation around it.

For brands and rights holders, that creates a clear opportunity. The strongest results will come from working with people who understand the audience, the culture and the context of the event. In a landscape where relevance matters more than reach, influence is no longer just about being seen. It is about being understood.

The real trick is resisting the urge to confuse visibility with value. Anyone can buy attention for a day; far fewer can earn relevance that lasts. And in sport, where the conversation moves fast, and the audience is rarely forgiving, that difference matters more than ever.


Ready to build influence that actually moves the needle?

If you’re looking to activate around sport in a way that feels modern, culturally fluent and genuinely effective, now is the moment to rethink how you work with creators. The brands winning today are partnering with the right voices, at the right moments, with the right story to tell.

If you want to build a creator strategy that’s rooted in cultural relevance and trust, we can help you identify the voices that matter and design campaigns that resonate with your target audiences. Let’s build something fans actually care about. Get in contact with our team today.